Gandhi & Churchill: The Epic Rivalry that Destroyed an Empire and Forged Our Age (repost)
Arthur Herman, "Gandhi & Churchill: The Epic Rivalry that Destroyed an Empire and Forged Our Age"
English | 2009-04-28 | ISBN: 0553383760 | 736 pages | EPUB | 1,3 MB
English | 2009-04-28 | ISBN: 0553383760 | 736 pages | EPUB | 1,3 MB
Popular historian Herman (How the Scots Invented the World, 2001) dramatizes the end of Britain’s rule of India through the lives of Mohandas Gandhi and Winston Churchill. The barrister met the politician once, in 1906, and each man’s subsequent relation to the issue of independence, up to its realization in 1947, guides Herman’s narrative. The tenor of the author’s presentation is that both Gandhi and Churchill’s visions of India’s future were illusory, and bear some blame for the convulsions of 1947 (partition, communal violence, and a Pakistani-Indian war).
Rooted in his youthful experiences in India, Churchill’s stout imperialism became an ever more impractical stance as Gandhi’s advocacy of independence gained momentum over the decades. Descriptive about the latter’s revered methods of nonviolence, Herman discerns an implied forcefulness behind them should, for example, a Gandhi fast touch off riots. If uncomplimentary toward Gandhi’s political acumen, Herman presents his criticisms subtly, without impeding the brisk narrative flow. Showing history eluding Gandhi and Churchill, Herman provocatively presents their efforts to shape it.